Breaking the Cycle: Toward Authentic Leadership

Prefer to watch the video? Click here.

Picture a CEO who spends more time crafting the perfect LinkedIn post than addressing their team’s concerns. Sound familiar? This is performative leadership—a growing problem where leaders prioritize image, charisma, and social media clout over substance, competence, and accountability. They chase likes, craft viral soundbites, and focus on optics, often at the expense of real problem-solving or team trust. In a world obsessed with digital validation, this behavior is amplified, eroding progress and fostering environments where loyalty to a leader’s persona overshadows merit or results.

But this isn’t just about bad habits—it’s a symptom of something deeper: mental complexity.

What Is Mental Complexity?

Mental complexity is how we process experiences, relationships, and information, growing more sophisticated as we move through developmental stages. These stages reflect how we construct our sense of self and the world. Most adults land in one of three stages:

• Socialized Mind (Stage 3): Identity comes from external validation—relationships, norms, or approval.

• Self-Authoring Mind (Stage 4): Identity is driven by internal values and independent thinking.

• Self-Transforming Mind (Stage 5): A rare stage integrating multiple perspectives and systems thinking.

The Socialized Mind stage is where many get stuck. Here, leaders seek approval, conform to expectations, and tie their worth to others’ perceptions. Research shows 58-65% of adults operate at this stage today, a reality that limits leadership effectiveness in our complex, fast-paced world.

The Socialized Mind and Performative Leadership

Leaders at the Socialized Mind stage often:

• Crave external validation (think social media likes or public praise).

• Make decisions based on optics rather than impact.

• Struggle with accountability when their self-image depends on others’ views.

This fuels performative leadership. For example, a manager might post about “team success” online while ignoring real team conflicts. Compare that to the Self-Authoring Mind stage, where leaders act from their values and focus on lasting results. Here’s a quick breakdown:

Stage	Leadership Behaviors
Socialized Mind (Stage 3)	Seeks approval, prioritizes image, follows norms
Self-Authoring Mind (Stage 4)	Acts on values, focuses on long-term impact

The problem? Moving to higher stages isn’t automatic. Social media and cultural pressures can keep leaders—and all of us—locked in validation-seeking mode. So, how do we shift toward authentic leadership?

A leader and his team

Solutions: Building Authentic Leaders

Here are practical steps to break the cycle at three levels:

1.      For Individuals: Grow Your Mind.

• Reflect Daily: Journal or meditate on your choices. Ask, “Am I doing this for approval or purpose?” Example: Write about a recent decision—did it feel authentic or performative?

• Seek Diverse Feedback: Talk to people outside your echo chamber to challenge your assumptions. Example: Ask a colleague for honest input on your leadership style.

2.      For Organizations: Support Growth

• Develop Beyond Skills: Offer programs on perspective-taking or handling ambiguity, not just technical training. Example: Run a workshop where leaders navigate a tough ethical dilemma.

• Reward Results: Measure success by outcomes (e.g., team performance) rather than visibility (e.g., social media posts). Example: Tie bonuses to employee satisfaction, not public mentions.

3.      For Society: Shift the Culture

• Boost Media Literacy: Teach people to see through online hype and value substance. Example: Share tips on spotting performative posts versus real leadership online.

• Push Education: Advocate for teaching mental growth in schools and workplaces—example: Lobby for adult development courses at local colleges.

Your Next Step

Performative leadership thrives when we stay stuck, chasing applause over impact. But we can change that. Reflect on your actions, redesign how we work, and push for a culture that values depth over flash. Imagine leaders who inspire trust and solve real problems, not just post about them.

Join the conversation: Share one way you’ve seen performative leadership play out, or a step you’re taking to grow authentically, in the comments below!